The Property Tax Mistake That Could Cost You Thousands | Sam Lockwood

Sam Lockwood joins Alastair Hoyne on Episode 8 of The Property Escalator

The Property Escalator™ · Episode 08

The property tax mistake
that could cost you thousands.

Alastair Hoyne in conversation with Sam Lockwood · Marquess Tax.

Sam Lockwood of Marquess Tax joins Alastair Hoyne to discuss early property tax advice, SDLT misconceptions, ownership structures, portfolio restructuring and planning the exit before commitment. Watch the conversation or read the article and full subtitle transcript below.

Episode released 15 November 2026 · Video duration 42 minutes 59 seconds.

Lightly edited from the supplied English subtitles, with speaker labels, paragraph breaks and timestamp links. The recording is authoritative where captions are unclear.

The conversation at a glance

Ask the tax question while you still have choices.

The most expensive time to ask a property tax question can be after the transaction has completed. By then, the buyer, the ownership structure and the legal documentation may already be fixed. Advice can explain the consequences, but the opportunity to shape the decision may have passed.

In Episode 8 of The Property Escalator™, Sam Lockwood of Marquess Tax joins me to explore how tax connects with acquisition, finance, ownership, development and the eventual exit.

Bring the whole transaction into the discussion.

Sam explains why he would ideally hear from an investor before an offer is made. Useful advice starts with who is buying, what is being acquired, how it will be funded and what the buyer intends to do with it. It also requires the broker, solicitor, lender and tax adviser to understand and work with the proposed structure.

That coordination matters for an existing portfolio too. Splitting a title, moving property into a company or separating a trading business from its premises can create tax consequences alongside a commercial opportunity. A transfer to a company needs examining as a transaction involving a separate legal entity.

A reclaim is not a substitute for planning.

The conversation examines common misunderstandings about linked transactions, replacing a main residence and the treatment of properties in poor condition. Sam discusses the evidential difficulty of arguing that a property is no longer a dwelling for SDLT purposes, and why a refund claim should begin with the facts and the applicable rules.

We also explore mixed purchases and transactions involving several dwellings. The lesson is to establish the treatment before commitment and reflect it in the appraisal, rather than assume that adding another asset or finding a particular label will produce a saving.

The structure must fit the strategy.

Personal ownership and company ownership serve different circumstances. Sam considers debt, the use of profits, administration, family involvement and succession. The discussion then follows the consequences through development, title splitting, group relief, buying shares in a property company and a later exit.

A lower initial tax cost is only one part of that decision. A structure needs to remain workable when assets move, leases are granted, profits are extracted or a company leaves a group.

  • Seek specialist input before the commercial and legal structure becomes fixed.
  • Include the buyer, property, funding, intended use and exit in the brief.
  • Check the conditions and evidence behind a proposed relief.
  • Assess the structure across the life of the investment.

These connections sit at the heart of The Finanze Framework™: strategy, finance, legal structure and exit need to work together.

The transcript records the speakers’ discussion and examples. SDLT applies in England and Northern Ireland; Wales and Scotland have separate property transaction taxes. Reliefs, connected-party rules, group relief and lending assessments have detailed conditions. The rates and examples mentioned in the recording are not a transaction-specific assessment. A company remains a connected party where the relevant rules apply, despite being a separate legal person. Obtain advice on the actual facts before acting.

Further reading: HMRC guidance on property transfers and whether a property remains suitable for use as a dwelling.

Subtitle transcript · 00:00

Opening and introduction.

Alastair Hoyne00:00

The most expensive time to ask a property tax question is often after you’ve already completed the transaction. By then, the ownership structure has been chosen, the SDLT position may have crystallised, and the strategy may already have created tax consequences that are difficult to unwind. So, in this conversation with property tax specialist Sam Lockwood, we’re going to look at when tax advice should enter a property transaction, what investors misunderstand about stamp duty, how ownership structure should really be approached, and why the eventual exit needs to be considered much earlier than most people think. Welcome to The Property Escalator.

I’m Alastair Hoyne, founder and CEO of Finanze Group and author of The Finanze Framework, Property Strategy & Finance Success. One of the principles behind the framework is that tax shouldn’t sit at the end of a property decision as an isolated calculation. The way you acquire the property, who owns it, what you intend to do with it, and how you eventually exit can all affect the tax position. Today I’m joined by Sam Lockwood from Marquess Tax, who specialises in property tax and has particular expertise around stamp duty and property transactions. Sam, thanks for joining me.

Sam Lockwood01:09

Thank you for inviting me.

Subtitle transcript · 01:11

When tax advice should enter the transaction.

Alastair Hoyne01:11

Sam, what’s the earliest point at which you wish a property investor or developer would speak to you and what do you need to understand about the strategy before you can give useful advice?

Sam Lockwood01:23

Well, that’s an interesting question. Typically, we find that clients actually raise the spectre of stamp duty land tax at the very last moment of a property transaction, often at the behest of maybe their mortgage adviser or solicitor. But the greatest advantage can be obtained before they’ve even made an offer on a property deal. And this is because it enables them to consider whether or not there’s any stamp duty saving and incorporate that into perhaps the commercials around that prospective deal or structure the deal in such a way that it’s not fixed before, you know, for example, contracts are exchanged. Once contracts are exchanged, most of what drives the tax is already fixed in place, i.e. who is buying, how the deal is going to be documented and what goes on the stamp duty land tax return.

Changing the structure of the deal afterwards can be complicated by the fact that the lending might be predicated on an approved structural reading in terms of what we need to know about the deal or the strategy before we can give any useful advice we need to understand who’s the buyer are they an individual, perhaps a couple or a company, whether they if they are individuals, if they own other property? What the property actually is it a house, a dwelling, a block of flats or apartments, a building with both residential and commercial aspects to it such as a shop or a house with an office in the grounds. Is it a home with a large amount of land, perhaps agricultural land, paddock land grazing land what the purchaser intends to do with the property?

Is it going to be a dwelling for them to occupy as their main residence? Are they intending to let it out or are they intending to just refurbish and sell it on? And also how the property is being funded can be a key component to how effective the advice is that we give.

Alastair Hoyne03:32

I think that’s the key starting point, isn’t it? Tax advice is much more useful when it can influence the structure before the transaction becomes irreversible. If the property finance, legal structure, and exit have already been decided, sometimes all the tax adviser can do is explain the consequences rather than actually help shape the decision.

Sam Lockwood03:53

That’s correct. If all of the factors have been determined in advance, we can only rely on those factors in ascertaining if there’s any potential relief claim. What we can’t do is input in such a way as to assist in potentially reducing the stamp duty if a different structure were to be pursued at an earlier point in the transaction, yes.

Alastair Hoyne04:14

And I think that’s interesting, right? Obviously, you and I, I’ve introduced you to a client of ours that we’re looking to lend some money to shortly. We’re about to go into valuation. We are proactively looking at their portfolio on the basis that they haven’t been actively managing it, because they’re busy operating their trading business, and that there is potentially money left on the table. As a result of restructuring their portfolios, splitting some titles on a semi-commercial, potentially re-gearing some industrial units, creating an opco/propco structure for their trading business with a lease issued to themselves to create an investment value.

And obviously, I’ve introduced you to them. Because obviously, there could be tax implications to restructuring because of course, they own everything in their personal names and they would probably be better suited to owning it by a company, but that has implications, so there’s real practical, you know, ability to help clients not just before they make a purchase, but even with existing properties.

Sam Lockwood05:13

And I think another important point about you know approaching the issue of tax as early as possible is you need to have all the other professional advisers involved in the transaction on board and singing from the same hymn sheet, so it might be well and good a tax adviser such as myself suggesting an approach that’s going to save the client stamp duty land tax and even having the, you know, mortgage broker on board. But we also need to, you know, ensure that the lender and the solicitor acting on behalf of all parties is you know, prepared to act on the advice that’s being given and that we can iron out any queries that they might have as early as possible to avoid any obstacles arising that might cause stress or potentially jeopardise the transaction entirely okay.

Subtitle transcript · 06:04

SDLT misconceptions and reclaim risks.

Alastair Hoyne06:04

Yeah. I mean, stamp duty is probably one of the areas where investors hear the most conflicting information. What do buyers most commonly misunderstand about SDLT reliefs and the difference between legitimate planning and simply chasing a reclaim after completion?

Sam Lockwood06:20

So I think there are, I can think of three main issues where there’s a high degree of confusion by buyers if I break these down. The first is what we call linked transactions. So, these are transactions which occur between the same purchaser and vendor and which are part of a series of transactions or there’s some sort of deal in relation to multiple transactions. Oftentimes, a buyer, let’s say they’re buying three apartments for five hundred thousand pounds each, they will assume wrongly and from the same vendor, sorry, they’ll assume wrongly that they will pay stamp duty land tax at the higher rate on each of those properties, where in fact, if it’s a linked transaction, they are paying stamp duty land tax at the total purchase price of all the properties.

So rather than paying stamp duty at higher rates on. A property worth 500,000 and paying that sum three times over, they’ll instead pay stamp duty land tax at 1.5 million. And that pushes the transaction up into higher percentage rates of stamp duty land tax. So, that’s the first misconception we often come across. Another misconception is typically people who are buying a new home to live in and they incorrectly either assume the higher rates for additional dwellings are applicable or not applicable and one such circumstance that regularly comes up and this is a misconception in fact by the conveyancing solicitor acting on behalf of the client is they’ll ask a client whether or not they own other property and so they might own a buy to let portfolio and therefore the solicitor will assume that the higher rates are immediately applicable because on the new main residence purchase because they own other property.

Where in fact, if you are selling your main residence and replacing it with a new main residence, regardless of whether or not you own other property, the higher rates don’t apply in that circumstance and this can save a purchase of five percent of the purchase price in stamp duty land tax. Getting this point right, there are a variety of other scenarios involving more idiosyncratic transactions. You know, maybe it’s to do with you know unmarried couples where someone has an interest in another property. It might be where someone is buying their first property in the UK. And they own a property overseas, but the value of that property is under 40,000 pounds because it’s not considered a major interest, the higher rates wouldn’t apply in that circumstance.

So the variety of issues around the higher rates. And the third one, I think that there’s the biggest misconception on this also leads into the issue of SDLT reclaims, because it’s a common error that is made when making an SDLT reclaim is around what is considered a uninhabitable dwelling for stamp duty land tax. And the importance of this is that if you’re dealing with a dwelling that’s habitable, then it’s subject to the residential rates of stamp duty land tax and often as an investor, this means paying the additional five percent surcharge whereas, if a property is deemed uninhabitable as a dwelling, then it’s not subject to the residential rates of stamp duty, it’s subject to the non-residential rates of stamp duty land tax.

And the highest rate or the highest percentage rate applicable at the non-residential rate is five percent of the purchase price. So, there can be significant tax savings if a property is deemed uninhabitable as a dwelling at the date of completion. However, through you know HMRC guidelines and a number of cases that have been heard at tribunal, HMRC have taken the view that a property isn’t simply uninhabitable because it’s uninhabitable at the point that the transaction completes if the property can be brought back into use as a dwelling and was previously used as a dwelling, then fundamentally their argument is that it continues to be a dwelling for stamp duty land tax, almost regardless of the amount of work that might need doing to bring the dwelling back into habitable and safe use.

So this has been a problem with regards to stamp duty land tax reclaims because tax agents have been promoting to you know, taxpayers that where they’ve bought a property that’s run down or requires some form of redevelopment or wasn’t immediately habitable as a dwelling, that they’re entitled to a refund and the historically, the process around this actually made it easier for the client to get a refund, but then potentially be subject to inquiry afterwards because HMRC operated a process now review later policy, that policy has now changed and HMRC will intercept these reclaims and deal with them as they arise, but they’re also threatening to punish taxpayers who even attempt to reclaim, even if there’s no historic underpayment of tax so, it’s something to be aware of because you know, the risk is that you could suffer a penalty if you make an invalid reclaim.

And they are particularly being promoted around the concept of uninhabitable property.

Subtitle transcript · 11:57

Mixed purchases and the facts behind relief.

Alastair Hoyne11:57

And I suppose you’ve also got that tactical approach, like we discussed on our own separate call the other day, where you buy a, let’s say, large luxury residential asset in London and add in a few commercial assets just to enable a lower SDLT purchase cost.

Sam Lockwood12:18

So I think when we were speaking the other day I drew your attention to the recent reporting on the sale of Nick Candy’s property Providence House for I think it was 265 million pounds and that transaction benefited from the non-resident or the purchaser paying the non-residential rate of stamp duty because the seller Nick Candy also, as well as selling the main house, sold the purchase of five additional dwellings, which meant that the purchaser could apply what we call the six or more rule. Or more simply, treat the transaction as non-residential for SDLT and pay significantly lower rate of stamp duty. In fact, the purchasers save themselves, it’s reported, about 18.5 million pounds of stamp duty.

Alastair Hoyne13:07

And of course, they could have just, you know, bought a garage somewhere else, right? They didn’t necessarily need to buy, you know, an expensive commercial asset in Mayfair, did they?

Sam Lockwood13:19

Yeah. The, they could look to buy a low value commercial unit. It’s just important that, if, for example, they were buying things like garages or land, or they were looking to transfer gardens that subsisted already for the benefit of another dwelling, that they didn’t use those because those were themselves, even though they don’t include them. Dwelling, would be regarded as residential for SDLT purposes. So, it’s better to buy something, you know, obviously in wholly commercial, like a shop or an office or some development land with planning consent. Yeah.

Alastair Hoyne13:57

Clearly, they can’t just go and buy one of those, you know, one square metre of Scotland so that they get the lower rate of SDLT and a lordship at the same time.

Sam Lockwood14:05

I was gonna say, and a lordship at the same time.

Alastair Hoyne14:06

Yes, I think that’s an important distinction, right? A legitimate relief or treatment depends on the actual facts of the transaction. It shouldn’t start with the desired refund and then work backwards to find an argument. From an investor’s perspective, the sensible time to establish the SDLT position is before commitment, when it can still feed into the cash requirement and the investment appraisal. And, you know, again, if you are buying anything residential, see if the vendor also happens to have some random commercial property that they can also package into the transaction. It might actually be cheaper overall. And, funnily enough, actually, Sam, I mean, I remember a transaction similar to that in Wales that we looked at a few years ago, where the client was buying a bunch of freehold blocks, they were buying it for a massive discount on the basis that the vendor wanted to give it to their children, but the children didn’t want it.

So they were just trying to sell it at a deep discount just to get rid of it. And they were actually willing to throw in a few extra garages for free. Whereas I actually suggested at the time, not actually aware of the tax implications, I literally said, well, let’s put a value on them regardless, even if they’re sold for a pound, so that we can get those valued as well, because they could unlock additional capital. But, you know, in hindsight, now, I would have been saying definitely to make sure you take those, because it’s going to reduce your actual SDLT burden.

Sam Lockwood15:27

That’s correct. And obviously an important point when dealing with transfers between connected parties is that regardless of what the transfer value is that’s been given that the understanding that the stamp duty is calculated based on the market value of the properties being transferred… I mean, I spoke to a client recently who didn’t seem to appreciate the distinction because they were looking to transfer a property to a company and didn’t believe they needed any stamp duty advice, because they were just going to transfer a very low value, which didn’t reflect the market value. And we’ve explained to them, that’s not how the stamp duty should be calculated.

And so yes, if for example, you’re transferring your own property, or properties to a limited company, and you also own a low value commercial unit that is, you know, included in that transaction, then you can ensure that at least a non-residential rate of stamp duty based on the current rules, will apply to all the properties being transferred?

Subtitle transcript · 16:33

Title splits and transfers to a company.

Alastair Hoyne16:33

Yeah, I mean, that’s, you know, I think that’s interesting, right? I mean, I think we see it quite a lot, especially with the title splitting transactions, where a client is, for example, separating the land from the house, whether that’s a dwelling or an investment property, and selling it, you know, well, they’re using the transfer of part process to move it into a company. And they always seem surprised when I say, well, make sure you get some advice around the CGT implication of the sale of the land, and the potential SDLT charge for the purchase. And they sort of say, well, yeah, but I’m just selling it to myself. And I’m like, yeah, but your legal entity is a separate legal identity.

So, as far as the market’s concerned, it’s a sale to a non-connected party so so it’s not a if you were just moving it to yourself cutting it cutting the title up, then it wouldn’t necessarily face the same charges, but you’re physically. Separating the land, creating a new title and registering it as being owned by a separate legal entity and therefore there is a both a sale and a purchase consideration. Yeah.

Sam Lockwood17:43

That’s correct. Exactly. And one of the problems. People in that sort of scenario often face is that where they’ve not considered the stamp duty land tax or other tax implications, as you say, like capital gains tax, it might not be revealed to them until very close to completion when the stamp duty land tax return is being prepared by their conveyancing solicitor, and assuming they’ve prepared it correctly, that there is indeed going to be a tax charge. And if they have not factored that in that might change the whole strategy in their mind altogether as to, you know, doing the transfer of part of the title to, for example, a limited company.

And of course, conveyancing solicitors often will set out that they are not tax advisers as part of their terms of business. So it’s not something that will be at the forefront of their mind. As part of their undertaking to the client. Yes.

Subtitle transcript · 18:40

Individual ownership or a limited company.

Alastair Hoyne18:40

I mean, I think that actually leads us to the sort of the next question I was going to ask you anyway, which is, you know, a lot of clients are, you know, to be honest, most of them come to me straight away saying, Alastair, I’m buying this for a limited company. Therefore, you know, SPV to be determined. Very rarely do I ever get anyone approaching me as an individual. It would be, unless it was an investment property, it would be a regulated transaction in the first place. But the question of individual versus company is an interesting one, right? Because as a lender or a broker, we tend to look at it from the perspective of affordability cover when it comes to exiting, for example, a bridge or getting a buy-to-let mortgage.

Based on your tax rate, your personal tax rate, if you own the property as an individual, you would generally pay from memory, because I don’t do a lot of buy-to-lets these days, but from memory, I think it’s 140% is the sort of affordability ICR calculation if you’re a higher rate taxpayer, and 120% if you’re a lower rate taxpayer. But if you own the property in a limited company, it remains 120% regardless. So that limited company structure means. You don’t need as high a rent payment to cover off the mortgage from an affordability perspective. But it goes beyond that, doesn’t it, Sam, right, in terms of whether or not it’s more efficient to own personally or in a limited company.

And are there scenarios when owning it personally actually make sense.

Sam Lockwood20:09

Indeed the decision to purchase through either a limited company structure, some other form of SPV, or indeed as an individual, very much depends on the goals, the you know the lending requirements and opportunities, and their long-term plans. A limited company might suit, for example, a higher rate taxpayer looking to build a residential portfolio where there’s going to be some debt, because the interest on the debt is deductible in calculating the actual profit subject to corporation tax. Whereas, you know if you’ve got someone who’s inherited property, perhaps, who’s a basic rate taxpayer, and there isn’t much debt. Actually, operating for a limited company structure could be more costly because not only will they be corporation taxed to pay on the profit, but then they’re going to have to extract the profit from the company and pay tax again, effectively double taxation on the same profit.

So, yeah, it very much depends on the individual circumstances and also in terms of long-term goals as well. Limited company structures can be more desirable if you’re building a portfolio and bringing other family members into the business, so a form of succession planning, and it broadens the opportunities to reduce the taxable value of the investment portfolio within the estate, for inheritance tax as well. So, you know, there’s a range of pros and cons to operating through a limited company structure and individuals need to take a personalised view as to whether or not it’s something, you know, that will benefit them both in the short term in terms of tax saved on stamp duty on purchase or tax, corporation tax, income tax on profit.

But then the more long-term view is to who’s going to inherit this portfolio when I’m gone? Do I need to bring other people into the business maybe in order to assist me as I get older, or as I expand the business or indeed you know, perhaps a lender requires, you know, the site of continuity in the business, as the initial business owners are sort of beginning to advance in age.

Alastair Hoyne22:30

And I think that’s where simple rules of thumb can become dangerous. I mean, I hear on the grapevine, a lot of brokers, especially unregulated brokers, will often say to a borrower that gets in touch with them, you should use a limited company. And I don’t think they’re thinking entirely in the client’s best interest when they say that. They’re thinking in their own interest, because if the client uses a limited company, They don’t need to be regulated with the FCA as a broker. They don’t need either the basic credit broking permissions or the full mortgage permissions. So, many clients will be told that general information about, you know, why a limited company is better to persuade them to use a structure that allows them to actually handle the transaction.

So, if you are being told by your broker that a limited company is a more suitable structure, but you happen to be, for example, a basic rate taxpayer and are just. An accidental landlord or not intending to build a portfolio, do get proper advice. And do get proper advice from a tax adviser like Sam, regardless of your situation. I mean, there isn’t one universally correct structure for every investor. Tax is an important part of the decision, but so is finance administration, asset protection, how income will be used, and what the eventual exit looks like. The structure needs to fit the strategy, rather than the strategy being distorted simply to chase one tax outcome.

Subtitle transcript · 23:54

Strategy, group structures and the exit.

Alastair Hoyne23:54

Sam, how can the intended strategy, as we’ve already briefly touched on, actually change the tax position? For example, if someone is buying to refurbish and hold, develop and sell, change the use, split an asset, or just trade the property. Rather than invest for the long term.

Sam Lockwood24:12

Yeah, so. Strategy is an important part of the tax dynamic to any transaction. Let’s take, for example, a client who has purchased a freehold site, perhaps it’s an existing large residential dwelling or it’s a commercial building, and they’ve purchased it in order that they might then renovate it. Maybe they’ve used some form of bridging finance or development finance. They intend to renovate it into multiple units as dwellings, flats, apartments, and then they want to look at an exit, for example, either by, yeah, raising finance or selling the property. What you might find for an individual such as that if certainly if they’re looking to refinance, what might be a practical approach to that client scenario is that they purchase the site through a limited company because there’s no advantage to not purchasing it for a limited company.

Both transactions will tend to be subject to the higher rate, subject to any potential reliefs that might be applicable. When they’ve completed the refurbishment or redevelopment of the site. Oftentimes when they then look at an exit and approach their broker, the broker will set out a strategy whereby they suggest granting leases long leases on each of the apartments or flats that they’ve built because that will enhance the overall market value and thereby the you know, the amount that they can actually raise on the exit. Now, where you’re operating through a company, you’ve then got the opportunity to set up a group of companies and on the grant of the lease, which would normally be a taxable event for both stamp duty land tax and could trigger a gain for corporation tax purposes.

If you’ve got a group of companies at this point, you could transfer or grant the leases to you know another proper another company within the group and benefit from something called group relief. Meaning that there’s no stamp duty land tax charge or corporation tax charge on the gain. But again long understanding long-term strategy is really important because, you know, I’ve dealt with clients before where, you know, they have, maybe they’re purchasing property you know, from a structure, you know, where the vendor has set up a structure similar to this but the important things to understand are that, you know, if you have, you know, you’re looking at buying a company, perhaps because that’s going to save you the stamp duty land tax, you’re going to instead pay stamp duty on the shares at 0.5 of a percent.

And that looks attractive. If, for example, a the vendor has operated a group structure where they’ve transferred properties into a subsidiary so that you can then buy the subsidiary, or historically they’ve done it. You need to be aware of this if you’re buying the shares because what you can create is what’s called a degrouping event, which might then mean that the stamp duty charge on the company that you’ve just bought on the historic transaction when you weren’t the owner comes back into charge so so yeah, understanding strategy is really important in determining you know, what the approach should be in terms of setting out the structure and understanding what the long-term objectives are also going to be important because once you’re in the structure, sometimes exiting the structure after purchase can have its own tax consequences, which can be quite adverse.

Yes.

Alastair Hoyne27:53

Yeah, we do a lot of title split transactions. So, that degrouping gem is really worth knowing about because, again, we do see a lot of clients hoping to buy the SPV that the leasehold title is sitting in rather than the property for that specific tax benefit. So, the degrouping concept is really worth knowing. I mean, we used to also have multiple dwelling relief, which made title splitting even more attractive, but I think that only exists in Wales now.

Sam Lockwood28:22

Wales and Scotland. They abolished it in England in June 2024 actually it’s rather disappointing because there was a consultation paper published by HMRC that was looking into the issues around multiple dwellings relief, or the issues they perceived, i.e. advantages taxpayers were gaining mainly on the purchase of a main residence with a granny annex and HMRC’s proposal to the government was, we just need to tighten up the legislation around this so the people who we didn’t intend to benefit from the relief no longer benefit from it instead the government used the proverbial sledgehammer to crack the walnut and instead they just abolish the relief entirely yeah.

Alastair Hoyne29:05

So, it’s fine, right? We can just obtain a variation of what MDR was previously applying by making sure we throw in a little commercial unit in Scarborough with every purchase anywhere.

Sam Lockwood29:20

Exactly. Or if you’re buying a portfolio or a block of apartments, just make sure that there’s at least six dwellings and you can benefit from the non-residential rate which oftentimes would have been lower than the rate of tax payable if you were buying blocks of apartments and historically applying multiple dwellings relief.

Alastair Hoyne29:41

Yeah. And, you know, using the sort of apportioned percentages to each unit, right.

Sam Lockwood29:46

I’ll just add one other point in terms of the question that you raised is also about, this is more important I think for a individual than for a company where they’re buying a property to develop and then sell as opposed to develop and then hold, is that there is a distinction for an individual in the buying property to redevelop and sell may be considered a trade and therefore the profit that you might earn on the property would be subject to income tax, as opposed if you buy a property, renovate it, hold it for a period of time as an investment and then sell it, the profit you make from the sales is instead subject to capital gains tax. So that’s important if you’re for example, a higher rate taxpayer and that you don’t want your profit subject to a 40 or 45% tax rate as opposed to an 18 or 24 percent tax rate.

Alastair Hoyne30:44

And that could also potentially, you know, lead to creating that sort of opco/propco structure so that you can, you know, use corporate tax rather than personal tax, right.

Sam Lockwood30:56

Correct, yeah. So, if you made a gain, regardless of whether it was a trade gain or an investment gain in a company both are subject to corporation tax that currently ranging between 19 and 25% yeah.

Alastair Hoyne31:12

I mean, that’s probably one of the strongest framework connections. Exit isn’t a separate event that suddenly appears years later. The decisions you make on the way in can affect the options and the tax consequences on the way out. So the best structure isn’t necessarily the one that produces the lowest immediate tax cost. It needs to make sense across the life of the investment.

Sam Lockwood31:34

That’s right. And, you know… Decisions made at the beginning of a transaction can affect, you know, the tax consequences later because transactions later are often taxed as separate and new transactions with their own tax consequence associated.

Alastair Hoyne31:54

And especially with the point that you brought up earlier with the de-grouping principle.

Sam Lockwood32:00

Yeah, indeed. Exactly.

Subtitle transcript · 32:03

Where specialist property tax advice helps.

Alastair Hoyne32:03

Sam, thanks again. Let’s talk about the work you do. What types of property transactions or tax issues are particularly well suited to you? Where do you think specialist property tax advice makes the biggest difference. And at what stage would you ideally want one of our clients, one of the viewers, a broker or a solicitor, actually getting you involved?

Sam Lockwood32:26

So our firm, Marquess Tax, specialises in three main areas of property tax. The first is stamp duty land tax, identifying structures that might reduce the tax burden on a purchaser, relief claims that might be applicable to a transaction we also advise clients on restructuring of property investment portfolios, typically the transfer of an individually owned portfolio to a limited company structure. And finally, we also advise clients on inheritance tax related issues, mainly to do with property, but also more broadly. And that’s a consideration often that we address with clients once they’ve restructured a portfolio for example, into a limited company within the area of stamp duty land tax specifically, the cases that we most commonly see are properties that are broadly residential in nature, mainly you know something like a rural property being purchased with what might be regarded as, you know, non-residential land or buildings.

So this could be an office that’s let out to, you know, a third party business, it might be, you know.

Alastair Hoyne33:42

A barn?

Sam Lockwood33:43

Yeah, well, yeah, it’s got to be you know, it’s got to be a business that’s using it in an office sense, I think, as opposed to a storage sense you’ve we often look out for you know large amounts of you know agricultural land, paddock land, grazing land, with these sorts of transactions, or indeed lots of woodland as well. We will advise clients on cases where they’re buying several dwellings in one go, like a block of flats, and ideally we’re looking out for the opportunity for clients to benefit from their six or more rule. Where clients are transferring jointly owned property to their own limited company, sometimes that transaction might not give rise to a stamp duty land tax charge.

Where that portfolio. Sorry, where that jointly owned property was held as part of a broader portfolio between those individuals. In some circumstances, we can look to advise clients where they’re purchasing a derelict property but there’s I would caveat that by saying, you know, there’s got to be severe structural issues that might even require the partial demolition of the property to put right, or if there’s severe contamination

Alastair Hoyne34:56

As you mentioned earlier, HMRC are doing anything to prove that it could be lived in, even if it means sleeping in a sleeping bag on floorboards that are coming out.

Sam Lockwood35:06

I mean, I had a client whose stamp duty land tax claim was rejected earlier this year, unfortunately. And that was before some additional case law came in that may have favoured their position subsequently but the property that they had acquired had you know, had a fire destroy the roof. They had no staircases. The property had been unoccupied in almost a decade. And there were no utilities, no kitchen or bathroom. And even cases such as that HMRC you know, are inclined to deny you know, our uninhabitable dwelling so you’ve got to be really careful of those ones.

Alastair Hoyne35:47

It almost sounds like HMRC would consider an umbrella a dwelling, right? It stops the rain hitting your head. So.

Sam Lockwood35:54

Mean, if you’d lived in it previously as a dwelling, an umbrella would be regarded as a dwelling in their eyes, I’m sure. But yeah the threshold, I think, is quite high. And therefore, as tax advisers, we’re really careful about saying to a client and advising a client that the non-residential rate should be applied on the basis that the property they’re buying is an uninhabitable dwelling, we really need to have evidence. That’s another key point. And this was came out in a conversation that I’d had with HMRC is that, you know, you need things like structural surveys which highlight in detail, you know, the issues and the costs associated to be correcting those issues as general renovation is regarded as, you know, general renovation is not is not regarded as being substantive enough to make a property uninhabitable as a dwelling

Subtitle transcript · 36:47

Property trader relief and qualifying conditions.

Sam Lockwood36:47

and the other one I’d mention as well is and this, we haven’t mentioned this previously is where a company’s buying a property from an individual who formerly occupied that dwelling in the previous two years as their main residence and where that company might be regarded as a property trader which is a company looking to buy a property then renovate it and sell it on subject to meeting one of four scenarios and some additional qualifying conditions those transactions may be regarded as exempt for SDLT. So, there might not be any stamp duty to pay, which can be extremely attractive for you know individually sorry companies who are investing in properties, maybe at auction, with a view to spend little money on them and then sell them on.

And one scenario, which I might elaborate on in a bit more detail, is where you’ve got a company buying a probate property that’s being sold by the personal representatives or executors acting for the estate of the deceased former owner you know, that’s one such qualifying scenario and where the company is going to spend less than, it’s regarded as the permitted amount, but it’s five percent of the purchase price with a lower amount of or minimum amount of ten thousand and an upper amount of twenty thousand if the company spends less than that renovating the property, it doesn’t let the property out or let anybody connected with the company occupy the property at any point, then all the conditions for the property trade relief in that scenario may have been met and the stamp duties zero which you know that’s a significant…

Alastair Hoyne38:22

There could be a strategy in that, right? With a you know an option agreement that allows those conditions to be met before the purchase takes place. But of course, you know, we’re not going to get that many people agreeing to like die before they sell it, right

Sam Lockwood38:34

Yeah. I mean, I think with these sorts of opportunities, often it becomes a modus operandi for the developer because they’ll say, okay, I’m buying a property for £150,000 or £200,000 at auction. I can commit to spending less than the permitted amount renovating the property. And my intention is to sell the property if they’re saving you know, 10, 15,000 pounds in stamp duty, that’s a significant cost and a profit margin that can be factored in. So often, you know, having gone down that route once, a developer or property trader will seek to identify similar opportunities in the future. Indeed.

Alastair Hoyne39:18

I mean, I’ve seen cases like that before. And again, I hadn’t connected the dots. You know, I used to think people were mad, you know, putting a lease place an option in place, a deposit down, renovating the property with the intention of selling it. And I’m thinking to myself, well, what if the vendor just turns around after the renovation and says, here’s your deposit back. Thanks very much for renovating my property. I’ll sell this at the higher value. But there probably was, there may have been, that may have just been madness. And it may have been that a particular tactic was being used for tax purposes.

Sam Lockwood39:47

Yeah, a strategy might well been in play. So.

Subtitle transcript · 39:51

Contacting Sam and the final question.

Alastair Hoyne39:51

If somebody listening to this hopefully lots of people right watching and listening on our podcast or YouTube channel, and you’re remembering to like it and subscribe. It’s the first time I actually said that, but you know, there we go. How can they get in touch with you, Sam?

Sam Lockwood40:08

They can reach out to us via our website, which is http://www.marquesstax.co.uk or alternatively, they can email us at info@marquesstax.co.uk those would probably be the best ways, alternatively, because most of the people we work with at clients we work with, come through their other professional advisers they could reach out via their broker, for example, if they were dealing with your firm, Alastair, they could seek an introduction through yourself and that is often the most helpful

Alastair Hoyne40:42

Or lending arm, of course.

Sam Lockwood40:44

That’s often the most helpful way because obviously you can then support them you can then make the necessary introduction. Detailing the transaction in a manner that helps us to identify potential opportunities.

Alastair Hoyne40:59

And we’ll share all of this information in the comments. But as you already heard from Sam, feel free to treat me as the PA. Write to me and I can introduce you to Sam personally. Feel free to flood me with inquiries. I don’t mind, because he’ll have to buy me a few drinks as a return favour. Sam, thank you so much for your time. I mean, as a quick final question for the audience, if an investor is about to exchange contracts tomorrow, what is the one tax question you would want them to make sure has been answered first?

Sam Lockwood41:29

One tax question I would want them to have identified if the correct stamp duty land tax is payable on the transaction and therefore we need to identify, you know, all those things I mentioned at the beginning about the transaction. Who’s buying? Who’s selling? What’s being purchased what’s the structure for purchase? You’re very much almost at the point of no return. So, if you are looking to benefit from a stamp duty land tax saving, just making sure you’ve spoken to someone like myself or another tax adviser or that you have confidence that your conveyancing solicitor has considered all the options before you sign the contract that the stamp duty position has been considered it thoroughly.

Alastair Hoyne42:14

Sam, thank you very much. I think the point I’d leave people with is that property tax shouldn’t be treated as the calculation that happens after the commercial decision has already been made. The acquisition position, ownership structure, intended use, finance and exit all interact with the tax position. So the right time to ask the question is while you still have choices, not after you’ve already committed to the transaction. Sam, thanks for joining me on The Property Escalator. I hope you’ve enjoyed the conversation.

Sam Lockwood42:41

You’re welcome, as always Alastair Hoyne.

About Sam Lockwood.

Sam Lockwood is a Director at Marquess Tax and a property tax specialist. In the conversation, he describes the firm’s work on SDLT, property portfolio restructuring and inheritance tax.

Visit Marquess Tax ↗ or email info@marquesstax.co.uk.

Continue the conversation.

Have a question about the episode? Join The Property Escalator™ investor Q&A group.

Explore all episodes or book a conversation with Alastair.

Continue the conversation

A broader perspective.A practical approach.

Arrange a Meeting ›
Alastair Hoyne registered logo Alastair Hoyne brand logo with registered trade mark symbol.

The personal website of Alastair Hoyne, founder, author and host.

info@alastairhoyne.com

This is the personal website of Alastair Hoyne®, sharing his work, publications and general commentary. Content, book extracts and examples are for information and education only. They do not constitute personalised financial, investment, mortgage, pension, tax, legal, valuation or other professional advice, a personal recommendation, an offer of funding or a recommendation that a transaction is suitable for you.

Property and investment values can fall. Returns, funding and refinancing are not guaranteed. Examples and illustrations depend on their stated assumptions and are not quotations. Obtain appropriate professional advice before acting. Services mentioned are provided by the relevant business under its own terms, eligibility criteria, assessment and applicable regulatory status. Not all services are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Reading this website or submitting an enquiry does not create an advisory relationship.

Original writing, book extracts, diagrams, illustrations, website designs, templates, software and other protected materials belong to Alastair Hoyne or their respective owners and licensors. FINANZE®, IT’S PERSONAL.® and the FINANZE IT’S PERSONAL.® logo mark are registered trade marks of Finanze Group Ltd. ALASTAIR HOYNE® is a registered trade mark of Alastair Hoyne. THE FINANZE FRAMEWORK™ and THE PROPERTY ESCALATOR™ are used as trade marks. Descriptive product wording following FINANZE® is not presented as separately registered. No exclusive ownership of generic property strategies or valuation concepts is claimed.

Reproduction, adaptation, republication, white-labelling, resale or other commercial reuse of protected materials requires prior written permission from the relevant rights holder, except as permitted by law or an applicable licence. Lawful quotation, statutory exceptions and ordinary search-engine and AI-search discovery remain permitted. See the Intellectual Property page, Terms & Conditions and Website Disclaimer for full details.

© 2026 Alastair Hoyne. All rights reserved.